For the past week we‘ve been watching The Patriot in history class. The movie is moving in some parts. There are incredibly tender moments, like when Susan finally speaks to her father and breaks down just as he’s leaving again. That part almost made me cry. Unfortunately, the latter part of the movie lacked that same emotional fervour, simply because I was too busy laughing.
And this is through no fault of the director. The movie was very accurate. I just can’t get over how silly warfare was back in that time.
Everyone arranges his- or herself in nice, neat lines. Then the two sides march forward. One side fires, reloads, while the other side fires. If you get shot, you get shot. It is, as Mr. Nowak puts it, “gentlemanly warfare”. And watching it on a television makes it look so absurd! The melée part with bayonets and swords isn’t so bad. But just the initial firing of musket volleys looks so ridiculously polite that I completely understand why guerrilla warfare surged in popularity afterward. Sure, you had to clean your uniform more often—but at least you were alive.
So that got me thinking. Some current rules of war make sense, like treating members of the Red Cross, Sweden, and American Idol with neutrality, etc. Others are just weird. Like one (well, it’s not really a rule so much as a “strategy”) is the idea of “mutually assured destruction” as a deterrent to nuclear war. 
What are some current rules of war or military strategies/policies that you think are absurd?
» 2 people have an opinion
That there are rules of war, and people in the US expect them to be followed by both sides, perfectly such as combat medics are not to be shot at. Since they are by definition unarmed and weapons they may have are to be used purely in defense of them selfs and the wounded they are treating. Or there are to be no civilian casualties, or the hiding of armed forces in the civilian population, yet countries and “terrorist” groups do it any ways. I find it stupidity that people would expect theses “laws” to be followed by every side, heck it is hard enough to prevent accidental killings of civilians and medics.
Leave your opinion
The Website field is optional, but you must enter your name, email address, and of course, a comment. In order to make it harder for bots to spam my blog, you need to answer a simple addition question. But if you select Remember me, then your details will be saved, and you won’t have to answer the question again.
Formatting
- Bold
**Bold text**- Italics
//Italic text//- Underline
__Underlined text__- Monospace
''Monospaced text''- Link
-
[[http://google.com/|Google search engine]]Bare URLs will automatically become links.
- Images
{{http://imageurl.com/image.png|Alternate text if the image does not load}}- Quotation
-
> This is a quotation.
> It can span multiple lines.
>
> Or even paragraphs, as long as each line has a > before it. - Unordered list
-
* List item (note two spaces preceding the asterisk)
* Second list item - Ordered list
-
- List item (note two spaces preceding the dash)
- Second list item - Definition list
-
t: Term (note two spaces preceding the t)
d: Definition (note two spaces preceding the d)
Bad things now are no drafts and low taxes (at least in america). Many people hate the war here and many of the same people don’t have a clue what is going on. if we had more at stake in the war i think people would be more outspoken, not just celebrities and radical politicians.
Saturday, May 5, 2007 at 12:33 PM